top of page

iPhones or Androids for staff: what actually matters

Writer: Adrian Bueno
Adrian Bueno
2 days ago
4 min read

Photo by fauxels

You are about to hand phones to a few people. It might be a new hire, a delivery crew or a sales rep who has been using their own handset for years. Someone says "just get iPhones", or you spot a deal on Android and it looks like the sensible choice.

 

Brand loyalty is the least useful way to decide. What matters is how you will manage the phones, how you will get them fixed, and how long they will stay safe to use. Judged on those three things, the answer is usually clearer than the usual argument suggests.

 

Start with what the phone has to do

A phone that only needs calls, email and a messaging app is a different purchase from one that runs a job-booking app, scans barcodes or takes photos on site in the rain. Write down the two or three things the phone must do every day, and check that the apps your business already relies on work properly on the platform you are leaning towards.

 

Most common business apps exist on both iPhone and Android. Some niche industry software, though, is built for one first and the other later, or not at all. Ask your software supplier rather than assuming.

 

Management matters more once you have more than two phones

With one or two phones, you can set them up by hand and trust people. Past that, the question is what happens when someone leaves, loses a phone or installs something they should not have.

 

Both Apple and Google offer ways to enrol company phones into a central management tool, so you can push settings, require a passcode, install the apps you need and wipe a lost phone remotely. Apple's route goes through Apple Business Manager. Google's is called Android Enterprise. Both work with the common management products, and neither is a clear winner for a small firm.

 

The practical difference is consistency. Apple makes the phone and the software, so every iPhone behaves much the same way. Android runs on many makes and models, and the management options and extra software can vary between them. If you choose Android, choose one manufacturer and a small number of models, and confirm they support proper enrolment. Mixing five brands is what makes Android a headache, not Android itself.

 

Think about the cracked screen before you buy

Every phone gets dropped eventually. Before you pick one, find out where it would be repaired and how long that takes. Apple has its own service network and authorised repairers, so the route is usually straightforward. With Android, it depends heavily on the brand. Some have good repair support in Ireland and some mostly send you back to the shop you bought it from.

 

Two questions are worth asking the seller. Can I get a replacement or loan phone while this one is away? And who handles the warranty, them or the manufacturer? For a person who needs their phone to work, a week without it costs more than the repair itself.

 

A modest case and screen protector is cheaper than any of it.

 

Lifespan is a promise about updates, not about hardware

A phone that still turns on but no longer gets security updates is a risk, especially if it holds customer details, email and banking apps. So the useful figure is how long the manufacturer commits to supplying updates for that specific model.

 

That period differs between makers and between models from the same maker. Do not rely on a general reputation. Look up the stated update commitment for the exact phone you are considering, and count it from today, not from when the model was launched. A cheaper phone with a short update window can turn out to cost more over three or four years than a dearer one that lasts.

 

Whose phone is it, and what happens when they leave

If staff use their own phones for work, you cannot easily require updates, passcodes or a remote wipe, and you may be holding business contacts and customer messages on a device you do not control. Company-owned phones solve most of that, but they come with the cost and the admin.

 

A middle route is to keep personal phones but separate work data from personal data using the tools both platforms offer. That takes a bit of setup, but it respects people's privacy and still lets you remove business data when someone moves on.

 

Whichever way you go, write down a one-page policy: who owns the phone, what must be on it, what happens if it is lost, and what is returned when someone leaves. Under data protection rules, customer data on a lost phone is your responsibility, so it is worth thinking this through before it happens.

 

A simple way to decide

If you want the least effort and your staff are not technical, iPhones tend to be easier to keep consistent. If you have a reason to prefer Android, such as a rugged handset, a particular app or a budget limit, it is a perfectly good choice as long as you standardise on a few models and check their update support and repair options.

 

Either way, decide how you will manage the phones before you order them, not after the first one goes missing.

 

If you want help working out what your phones and the data on them should be doing for the business, Fast Mercury Marketing in County Kildare is happy to talk it through.

Comments


bottom of page