top of page

Choosing between ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Copilot

Writer: Adrian Bueno
Adrian Bueno
Nov 4
3 min read

Updated: Nov 13


Photo by Vladimir Sputnik


You have probably heard all four names by now, and someone at a networking event has told you theirs is the best. You do not need the best. You need the one that helps with what you actually do on a Tuesday: answer customer emails, quote for a job, tidy up a document, make sense of a spreadsheet you did not build.


Benchmark tables are written for people comparing models. This is for someone with a business to run, and the differences that matter are smaller and more practical than the headlines suggest.


Start with the office software you already pay for

If your business runs on Microsoft 365, Copilot is built into Outlook, Word, Excel and Teams, and it can work with the emails and files you already have. If you run on Google Workspace, Gemini plays the same role in Gmail, Docs and Sheets. The appeal is not that the underlying model is cleverer. It is that you stop copying and pasting between windows. Summarising a long email thread or drafting a reply happens right where the thread is.

What is included and what costs extra varies by plan and changes often, so check your own account and the provider's current pricing page rather than trusting anyone's summary, including this one. Also, the version built into your software and the standalone chat version of the same name can behave differently.


For writing that sounds like you, try Claude and ChatGPT

A lot of Tuesday work is words: a reply to an awkward customer, a proposal, a job ad, a note to staff. Claude and ChatGPT are both widely used for this. Some people find Claude's drafts read a little more naturally, others prefer ChatGPT's. That is taste, not a rule, so test it. Paste in two emails you wrote yourself and ask each tool to write a third in the same style. Whichever draft needs fewer edits is your answer.


Both can also read a long document, such as a supplier contract or a tender, and tell you what is in it. Treat that as a first pass. Read the clauses that matter to you yourself.


ChatGPT is the all-rounder, which helps and also clutters

ChatGPT tends to offer the widest set of features. It can work with images, look at spreadsheets, search the web and connect to add-ons. If your week is varied, with some copywriting, some pricing maths and a photo of a handwritten delivery note you want typed up, one tool that does a bit of everything is handy.


The cost is choice. There are many options and settings, and features move between plans. Start with plain chat and add extras only when you have a specific reason.


Think before you paste in anything about a customer

Whichever you choose, the free personal version and the paid business version are not necessarily treated the same way with your data. Providers differ on whether your conversations can be used to improve their models, and the setting is not always where you would expect it.


Customer names, health details and staff matters are personal data under GDPR. Read the data settings and the provider's business terms first, or leave the personal details out. A simple habit is to swap real names for 'Customer A' before you paste. It takes ten seconds.


A one-week test that costs next to nothing

Pick three real tasks from this week. For example, reply to a tricky enquiry, summarise a long document, and ask questions of a spreadsheet. Run each through two tools and note which needed fewer corrections and which you would actually open again.


Use the free versions first. Pay for one only when you hit a limit you genuinely feel, and be wary of paying for several at once. Switching later is not a big deal, because what you have learned is how to describe a job clearly in plain English, and that carries over to any of them.


If you would rather have AI built into your marketing and reporting so it runs without anyone opening a chat window, Fast Mercury Marketing in County Kildare can help.

Comments


bottom of page